Archives > Clan World Discussion
Clan Rating System
Al:
--- Quote from: Raging Mage2 on October 15, 2012, 10:51:44 am ---
--- Quote from: Al on October 15, 2012, 07:53:24 am ---
--- Quote from: Raging Mage2 on October 15, 2012, 07:36:46 am ---
--- Quote from: Al on October 15, 2012, 07:26:12 am ---Well that was how RAW ran and eventually it didn't work anymore and fell apart. I want to see if making a system that rates a clan by many factors, not just only who beats who. Anybody clan rally up people and try to knock a clan off a rank right?
--- End quote ---
That's recruiting and warring isnt it?..
There isnt much else to wilderness clans.
--- End quote ---
What would it mean if 100 randomers gathered together and knocked off the #1 rank? That doesn't measure how good the clan is at all?
--- End quote ---
If they're in your clan it does.
--- End quote ---
If it was a temporary rally then I wouldn't add it to the toplist on the rating system. The "clan" wouldn't be viable to join at all. I mentioned that the equation could factor in things like how long the leader or members have stayed in the clan. That alone would wipe out it. Beating a clan wouldn't mean you're automatically ranked above it. It would make the clan you beat lose credibility and drop in rating, but certainly not the old of of RAW rankings. If clans did start beating them, then eventually their rank would drop lower and lower.
Al:
--- Quote from: Raging Mage2 on October 15, 2012, 10:51:44 am ---
--- Quote from: Al on October 15, 2012, 07:53:24 am ---
--- Quote from: Raging Mage2 on October 15, 2012, 07:36:46 am ---
--- Quote from: Al on October 15, 2012, 07:26:12 am ---Well that was how RAW ran and eventually it didn't work anymore and fell apart. I want to see if making a system that rates a clan by many factors, not just only who beats who. Anybody clan rally up people and try to knock a clan off a rank right?
--- End quote ---
That's recruiting and warring isnt it?..
There isnt much else to wilderness clans.
--- End quote ---
What would it mean if 100 randomers gathered together and knocked off the #1 rank? That doesn't measure how good the clan is at all?
--- End quote ---
If they're in your clan it does.
--- End quote ---
If it was a temporary rally then I wouldn't add it to the toplist on the rating system. The "clan" wouldn't be viable to join at all. I mentioned that the equation could factor in things like how long the leader or members have stayed in the clan. That alone would wipe out it. Beating a clan wouldn't mean you're automatically ranked above it. It would make the clan you beat lose credibility and drop in rating, but certainly not the old of of RAW rankings. If clans did start beating them, then over their rank would drop lower and lower.
I've been thinking about a refresh in rankings after a time period, and then an all-time ranking list, kind of like the pound-for-pound list used in boxing. After each period new clans would be able to sign-up for a shot at the top. Clans that were already on the list or have history get priority, and then after the off-season or sign-up period ends clans would have to manually enter on the list by taking whatever rank is comes next at the bottom.
Raging Mage2:
Oh, you didn't want opinions. Sorry
Owen:
--- Quote from: Al on October 15, 2012, 07:53:24 am ---
--- Quote from: Raging Mage2 on October 15, 2012, 07:36:46 am ---
--- Quote from: Al on October 15, 2012, 07:26:12 am ---Well that was how RAW ran and eventually it didn't work anymore and fell apart. I want to see if making a system that rates a clan by many factors, not just only who beats who. Anybody clan rally up people and try to knock a clan off a rank right?
--- End quote ---
That's recruiting and warring isnt it?..
There isnt much else to wilderness clans.
--- End quote ---
What would it mean if 100 randomers gathered together and knocked off the #1 rank? That doesn't measure how good the clan is at all?
--- End quote ---
That's why fights for RAW rank usually had rules, meaning it was a fair fight, and when would you ever have 100 randomers fighting the top clan?
BeeBee:
Pretty sure WG mass rallied vs Bk back in the day #
Well according to ex Bk, when apps were meant to close WG ml grew by like 80 #
OT:
Most clans ddos and cheat now. Sometimes in defence though. In nbk we ddos Reiss.